2027 Baseball Hall of Fame Odds: Posey Favored, Utley Next

San Francisco Giants president of baseball operations Buster Posey before the game against the Miami Marlins at Oracle Park
San Francisco Giants president of baseball operations Buster Posey may be headed to Cooperstown (Imagn)
1
48 Players redeemed today!
DraftKings Sports logo
Spend $5, Get $150 In Bonus Bets, *Paid Within 14 Days!
DraftKings Sports Bonus Code
No Code Required
Visit Site

DraftKings Sports Welcome Offer Ts and Cs: GAMBLING PROBLEM? CALL 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MY-RESET, (800) 327-5050 or visit gamblinghelplinema.org (MA). Please Gamble Responsibly. 888-789-7777/visit ccpg.org (CT), or visit www.mdgamblinghelp.org (MD), 1-800-981-0023 (PR). 21+ and present in most states. (18+ DC/NH/PR/WY). Void in CAN. Eligibility restrictions apply. On behalf of Boot Hill Casino (KS). Pass-thru of per wager tax may apply in IL. 1 per new DraftKings customer. $5+ first-time bet req. Max. $150 issued as non-withdrawable Bonus Bets that expire in 7 days after issuance. Stake removed from payout. Reward issued as $50 in Bonus Bets every 7 days via click-to-claim for 14 days. 7 days = 168hrs. Terms: sportsbook.draftkings.com/promos. Ends 8/23/26 at 11:59 PM ET. Sponsored by DK.

Buster Posey is a heavy favorite to be elected to the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2027, listed at -650 on Bookies.com’s hypothetical odds, an implied 86.7% chance of clearing the 75% bar in his first year on the ballot. Chase Utley is the only other candidate near even money at +110, and the Baseball Writers’ Association of America (BBWAA) results arrive Jan. 19.

The 2027 ballot has 27 candidates, 14 of them first-timers, and the Contemporary Baseball Era Committee votes on eight managers, executives and others on Dec. 6. Use the widget below for every candidate, then read on for how each case breaks down.

Hall of Fame OddsUpdated Nov. 16, 2026

Who Gets Into the Baseball Hall of Fame in 2027? Odds for Every Candidate

The 2027 BBWAA ballot and Contemporary Baseball Era slate were revealed this week. Odds show each candidate's chance of clearing the 75% bar before the July 25 induction in Cooperstown.

27Candidates
14First-timers
75%Needed to elect
Jan. 19Results day

Odds are the chance each player is named on 75% of BBWAA ballots. Tap a row for vote history and the case for and against. The vertical line on each vote bar marks 75%. Expected BBWAA class size: 1.6 players.

Leading candidates

1Buster PoseyC · Giants · First year on ballotFavorite-65086.7% implied

A 12-year Giants career packed with hardware: Rookie of the Year, NL MVP, a Gold Glove and three World Series titles. Voters tend to treat a résumé like that as a first-ballot case despite the shorter career.

Seasons12
All-Star picks7
Silver Sluggers5
WS titles3
2012 NL MVP2010 NL ROY2016 Gold GloveDebut
2Chase Utley2B · 4th year on ballotFavorite+11047.6% implied

The only holdover above 50% last cycle. Climbed from 28.8% to 39.8% to 59.1%, and needs 15.9 more points on a ballot with only one slam-dunk newcomer.

2026 vote
59.1%
2026 vote59.1%
Gap to 75%15.9 pts
Last jump+19.3 pts
Ballot year4th
6x All-StarTrending upWeak debut class
3Félix HernándezRHP · Mariners · 3rd year on ballotContender+10009.1% implied

The biggest riser of the 2026 ballot, more than doubling his debut share. Another jump of that size would put him in range, but it is a lot to ask twice.

2026 vote
46.1%
2026 vote46.1%
Gap to 75%28.9 pts
Last jump+25.5 pts
Debut vote20.6%
2x ERA champBiggest riser
4Andy PettitteLHP · 9th year on ballotContender+14006.7% implied

Gained 20.6 points last cycle to reach 48.5%, but this is his ninth ballot and the clock is nearly out. He needs 26.5 more points in a single year.

2026 vote
48.5%
2026 vote48.5%
Gap to 75%26.5 pts
Last jump+20.6 pts
Ballot year9th
5x WS champClock running
5Alex RodriguezSS · 6th year on ballotContender+40002.4% implied

The numbers say top-10 position player ever, but PED ties keep capping the vote. A new high of 40.0% last year still left him 35 points short.

2026 vote
40.0%
2026 vote40.0%
Gap to 75%35.0 pts
Last move+2.9 pts
Ballot year6th
PED stigmaSlow climb
6Cole HamelsLHP · Phillies · 2nd year on ballotLong shot+80001.2% implied

Posted the best debut share of the 2026 class at 23.8%. His 123 ERA+ and 57.9 bWAR beat Jon Lester's marks in nearly the same innings.

2026 vote
23.8%
2026 vote23.8%
Gap to 75%51.2 pts
ERA+123
bWAR57.9
Best 2026 debut
7Bobby AbreuOF · 8th year on ballotLong shot+100001.0% implied

Reached 30.8% on his seventh try. Two ballots remain after this one, and he needs a historic late surge.

2026 vote
30.8%
2026 vote30.8%
Gap to 75%44.2 pts
Ballot year8th
2 ballots left after this
8Jimmy RollinsSS · 6th year on ballotLong shot+150000.7% implied

Sitting at 25.4%. Steady support, but nothing suggests a leap big enough to matter this year.

2026 vote
25.4%
2026 vote25.4%
Gap to 75%49.6 pts
Ballot year6th
Slow build
9Jon LesterLHP · First year on ballotLong shot+150000.7% implied

Best of the newcomers behind Posey: 200 wins, five All-Star nods and three World Series titles over 16 seasons. His 117 ERA+ and 43.5 bWAR trail Hamels, which could cap his vote.

Wins200
All-Star picks5
WS titles3
bWAR43.5
200 wins3x WS champDebut
10Dustin Pedroia2B · 3rd year on ballotLong shot+250000.4% implied

Received 20.7% in his second year. Needs a long run of gains.

2026 vote
20.7%
2026 vote20.7%
Gap to 75%54.3 pts
Ballot year3rd
11Mark BuehrleLHP · 7th year on ballotLong shot+250000.4% implied

Spent five ballots between 5.8% and 11.4%, then jumped to 20.0% last year. The momentum is real but the gap is huge.

2026 vote
20.0%
2026 vote20.0%
Gap to 75%55.0 pts
Ballot year7th
Late riser
12Omar VizquelSS · 10th and final yearLong shot+100000<0.1% implied

Faded to 18.4% and is out of ballot years after this vote.

2026 vote
18.4%
2026 vote18.4%
Gap to 75%56.6 pts
Ballot year10th (final)
Final ballot
13David Wright3B · 4th year on ballotLong shot+500000.2% implied

Received 14.8% last cycle. Still building a base.

2026 vote
14.8%
2026 vote14.8%
Gap to 75%60.2 pts
Ballot year4th
14Francisco RodríguezRHP · 5th year on ballotLong shot+100000<0.1% implied

Sixth all-time in saves, but relievers face a steep bar. His share has stayed between 7.8% and 11.8% across four ballots.

2026 vote
11.8%
2026 vote11.8%
Gap to 75%63.2 pts
Saves rank6th all-time
Reliever bar
15Torii HunterOF · 7th year on ballotLong shot+100000<0.1% implied

Hovering just above the 5% line at 8.7%. Staying on the ballot is the realistic goal.

2026 vote
8.7%
2026 vote8.7%
Gap to 75%66.3 pts
Ballot year7th
Near 5% line

Rest of the ballot: first-time longshots

Jake ArrietaRHP+100000
Jay BruceOF+100000
Asdrúbal CabreraSS+100000
Starlin CastroSS+100000
Wade DavisRHP+100000
Brett GardnerOF · Yankees lifer+100000
Andrew MillerLHP+100000
Pablo Sandoval3B+100000
Ervin SantanaRHP+100000
Kyle SeagerMariners lifer+100000
Joakim SoriaRHP+100000
Ryan ZimmermanNationals lifer+100000
8Candidates
16Committee voters
12Votes to elect
Dec. 6Vote day

The Contemporary Baseball Era Committee considers managers, executives and umpires whose biggest impact came after 1980. A 16-member panel of Hall of Famers, executives, media and historians votes, and 75% (12 votes) elects. Expected committee class size: 1.5.

1Bruce BochyManager · Giants, Rangers, PadresFavorite-15060.0% implied

Four World Series titles across two franchises, 2,252 wins (sixth all-time) and one of only three managers to take three clubs to the Fall Classic. The most complete résumé on the ballot.

WS titles4
Managerial wins2,252
All-time rank6th
4 rings3 WS franchises
2Dusty BakerManager · Giants, Cubs, Reds, Nationals, AstrosContender+25028.6% implied

Eighth all-time with 2,183 wins and the only manager to lead five different teams to the postseason. The 2022 Astros title answered the lone knock on his résumé.

Managerial wins2,183
All-time rank8th
Postseason clubs5
WS titles1
Only manager w/ 5 playoff clubs
3Lou PiniellaManager · Reds, Mariners, CubsContender+50016.7% implied

Swept the A's in the 1990 World Series with a wire-to-wire Reds team and won 116 games with the 2001 Mariners. MLB.com notes he has fallen one vote shy on earlier Era Committee ballots.

WS as manager1 (1990)
WS as player2
Best season116 wins
Manager of Year2x
Near miss before
4Brian SabeanExecutive · Giants GMContender+55015.4% implied

Ran the Giants for 29 years, building three World Series winners (2010, 2012, 2014) and four NL pennants. Pairs naturally with a Bochy vote.

Years as GM29
WS titles3
NL pennants4
Exec of Year2x (BA)
29 years in SF
5Joe MaddonManager · Rays, Cubs, AngelsLong shot+10009.1% implied

Led the Cubs to the 2016 title and ended a 108-year drought, and took the Rays to the 2008 World Series. Three Manager of the Year awards, but only one ring.

Manager of Year3x
WS title2016
Drought ended108 yrs
Pennants2
Ended 108-year drought
6Sandy AldersonExecutive · A's, Padres, MetsLong shot+12007.7% implied

Built the A's teams that reached three straight World Series (1988-90) and won in 1989, then guided the Mets to the 2015 pennant. Elected to the A's Hall of Fame in 2026.

A's pennants3 (1988-90)
A's title1989
Mets pennant2015
A's HOF2026
3 straight WS trips
7Ted TurnerOwner · BravesLong shot+12007.7% implied

Owned the Braves from 1976 to 1996, including the 1995 title and the Maddux-Smoltz-Glavine rotation, and founded TBS and CNN. Turner died on May 6, which could bring a sentimental push.

Braves owner1976-96
WS title1995
FoundedTBS, CNN
DiedMay 6
Posthumous bid
8Bill WhitePlayer, broadcaster, NL presidentLong shot+25003.8% implied

Eight-time All-Star and seven-time Gold Glove first baseman, then NL president from 1989 to 1994, the first Black league president in major North American sports. Received the Buck O'Neil Award in 2026.

All-Star picks8x
Gold Gloves7x
Career HR202
NL president1989-94
Buck O'Neil Award
1.6Exp. BBWAA class
1.5Exp. committee class
3.1Exp. total class

BBWAA class size

No one electedBBWAA shutout in January+17505.4% implied
Exactly 1 electedMost likely Posey alone+14041.7% implied
Exactly 2 electedPosey and a second name+13542.6% implied
3 or more electedNeeds a surge beyond Utley+88010.2% implied

Top-two scenarios

Posey and Utley both electedThe top two names clear 75% together+14041.7% implied
Posey elected, Utley falls shortUtley needs one more year+12045.5% implied
Utley elected, Posey falls shortPosey misses 75% on debut+15006.2% implied

Committee class size

Committee elects no oneAll 8 miss the 12-vote line+57014.9% implied
Committee elects exactly 1Bochy is the likeliest+15539.2% implied
Committee elects 2 or moreBochy plus a second name+11546.5% implied

Combined 2027 class

Class of 2027: 0-1 inductedBBWAA and committee combined+9909.2% implied
Class of 2027: exactly 2 inductedCombined total+31024.4% implied
Class of 2027: 3 or more inductedCombined total-20066.7% implied

Ballot survival

Lester stays on ballot (5%+ in 2027)Needs only 5% to return-46082.1% implied

Data: National Baseball Hall of Fame, MLB.com, CBS Sports. 2026 vote shares from the Hall of Fame and MLB.com. Updated: November 16, 2026.

Odds are hypothetical, set by Bookies.com editors for entertainment purposes, and are not offered by any sportsbook. Implied probabilities carry no margin. Class-size props assume independent outcomes.

Buster Posey Hall of Fame odds: a first-ballot favorite at -650

Posey’s résumé is dense for a 12-year career: 2010 NL Rookie of the Year, 2012 NL MVP, a 2016 Gold Glove, seven All-Star selections, five Silver Sluggers and three World Series titles with the Giants. Voters have tended to treat that kind of hardware as a first-ballot case even when the career is shorter than usual for a catcher.

The -650 price implies 86.7%, which still leaves room for a miss. Debut candidates can land short of 75% on the strength of a short career alone, and Bookies.com lists Posey missing on his first try, with Utley getting in, at +1500 (6.2%). The most likely outcome is Posey elected on his first ballot, with a second name deciding whether the class is one or two players.

Chase Utley and the holdovers

Chase Utley (+110, 47.6%). Utley is the only holdover above 50% last cycle. His vote climbed from 28.8% to 39.8% to 59.1%, and he now needs 15.9 more points in his fourth year. The 2027 ballot has one slam-dunk newcomer in Posey, which helps a candidate who is already trending up.

Félix Hernández (+1000, 9.1%). The biggest riser of the 2026 ballot, he went from 20.6% on his debut to 46.1%, a 25.5-point jump. Another jump of that size would put him in range, but a 28.9-point gap is a lot to close twice in a row.

Andy Pettitte (+1400, 6.7%). He gained 20.6 points last year to reach 48.5%, but this is his ninth ballot and he needs 26.5 more points in a single year.

Alex Rodriguez (+4000, 2.4%). The numbers argue for a top-10 position player ever, but PED ties keep capping the vote. A new high of 40.0% last year still left him 35 points short, and his last move was only +2.9 points.

Newcomers and others. Jon Lester (+15000) is the best of the new class behind Posey, with 200 wins, five All-Star nods and three World Series titles, though his 117 ERA+ and 43.5 bWAR trail Cole Hamels (+8000, 123 ERA+, 57.9 bWAR). Omar Vizquel (+100000) is on the ballot for the final time after falling to 18.4%. Lester staying on the ballot by reaching 5% is -460 (82.1%).

Contemporary Baseball Era Committee odds

The Contemporary Baseball Era Committee votes Dec. 6 on managers, executives and others whose biggest impact came after 1980. A 16-member panel votes, and 12 votes (75%) elects. Bruce Bochy is the favorite at -150.

CandidateRoleOddsImplied
Bruce BochyManager-15060.0%
Dusty BakerManager+25028.6%
Lou PiniellaManager+50016.7%
Brian SabeanExecutive+55015.4%
Joe MaddonManager+10009.1%
Sandy AldersonExecutive+12007.7%
Ted TurnerOwner+12007.7%
Bill WhitePlayer, broadcaster, NL president+25003.8%

Bochy has four World Series titles and 2,252 wins, sixth all-time. Baker is eighth with 2,183 wins and is the only manager to take five different teams to the postseason. Piniella won the 1990 World Series with the Reds and 116 games with the 2001 Mariners, and MLB.com notes he has fallen one vote short on earlier Era Committee ballots. Sabean built three Giants World Series winners and pairs naturally with a Bochy vote. Turner died on May 6, which could bring a sentimental push for the former Braves owner.

Hall of Fame class size odds

Bookies.com’s model expects 1.6 players from the BBWAA vote and 1.5 from the committee, a combined class of about 3.1.

PropOddsImplied
BBWAA elects no one+17505.4%
BBWAA elects exactly 1+14041.7%
BBWAA elects exactly 2+13542.6%
BBWAA elects 3 or more+88010.2%
Posey and Utley both elected+14041.7%
Posey elected, Utley falls short+12045.5%
Utley elected, Posey falls short+15006.2%
Committee elects no one+57014.9%
Committee elects exactly 1+15539.2%
Committee elects 2 or more+11546.5%
Combined class: 0 to 1 inducted+9909.2%
Combined class: exactly 2 inducted+31024.4%
Combined class: 3 or more inducted-20066.7%

Class-size props assume each candidate’s outcome is independent.

How Hall of Fame voting works and key dates

BBWAA members vote on the player ballot, and a candidate needs to be named on 75% of ballots to be elected. Players who fall below 5% drop off, and each candidate gets a maximum of 10 years, which is why 2027 is Omar Vizquel’s last chance. The Contemporary Baseball Era Committee uses the same 75% bar, which on a 16-member panel means 12 votes.

DateEvent
Dec. 6, 2026Contemporary Baseball Era Committee vote
Jan. 19, 2027BBWAA results announced
July 25, 2027Induction ceremony in Cooperstown

Baseball Hall of Fame odds FAQ

Is Buster Posey going to make the Hall of Fame? Bookies.com lists Posey at -650 to be elected on his first ballot, an implied 86.7% chance. His case rests on a 2012 NL MVP, three World Series titles and seven All-Star selections over 12 seasons.

Who is on the 2027 Baseball Hall of Fame ballot? The 2027 BBWAA ballot has 27 candidates, 14 of them first-timers. Buster Posey and Jon Lester are the headline newcomers, and Chase Utley, Félix Hernández, Andy Pettitte and Alex Rodriguez lead the holdovers.

When will the 2027 Hall of Fame results be announced? BBWAA results are due Jan. 19, 2027. The Contemporary Baseball Era Committee votes earlier, on Dec. 6, and inductees are honored in Cooperstown on July 25.

How many votes does it take to get into the Baseball Hall of Fame? A player needs to be named on 75% of BBWAA ballots. The Contemporary Baseball Era Committee also needs 75%, which is 12 of its 16 votes.

Will Alex Rodriguez make the Hall of Fame? In this model he is +4000, a 2.4% implied chance in 2027. He reached a new high of 40.0% last year but remains 35 points short, and PED ties have capped his support.

Will Chase Utley make the Hall of Fame in 2027? Utley is +110 (47.6%). He is up from 28.8% to 39.8% to 59.1% over three ballots and needs 15.9 more points.

Who will be in the Hall of Fame class of 2027? The most likely outcome is Buster Posey from the BBWAA vote and Bruce Bochy from the committee. Bookies.com puts three or more total inductees at -200 (66.7%) and an expected class of about 3.1.

Sources and methodology

Odds are hypothetical, set by Bookies.com editors for entertainment purposes, and are not offered by any sportsbook. Implied probabilities are converted from American odds with no margin. Class-size props assume independent outcomes. 2026 vote shares and candidate lists come from the National Baseball Hall of Fame and MLB.com, with additional ballot context from CBS Sports.

Sources: National Baseball Hall of Fame, MLB.com, CBS Sports