Miami Dolphins 2026 Head Coach Odds: Belichick, Kingsbury In Play?
Promo Code: BOOKIESBG150
The half-decade honeymoon in Miami Gardens appears to be officially over, with Dolphins head coach Mike McDaniel dropping what might as well have been a must-win game across NFL betting sites to the Buffalo Bills 31-21 on Thursday night.
The 10-point loss knocks Miami to 0-3 for the year, coming on the heels of losses to the Indianapolis Colts and New England Patriots to open the year, effectively closing the door on the 42-year-old coach’s time with the Dolphins.
All told, McDaniel’s record is now 28-26 with two postseason berths in 2022 and 2023, though his time in Miami Gardens has gotten strained as the club staggered through an 8-9 campaign in 2024 followed by this year’s clunker of a start. With the winless Jets and Panthers up next, the Dolphins may give an interim coach a soft launch in the coming days.
With that in mind, Bookies.com's Adam Thompson broke down the odds on who will replace McDaniel as the Dolphins next head coach, with a host of NFL coordinators and NCAA head coaches atop our list, plus a 8-time Super Bowl champion who'd welcome a chance to play the Patriots twice a year...
| Coach / Position | Odds | Implied Probability |
|---|---|---|
| Kliff Kingsbury, Commanders OC | +500 | 16.7% |
| Bill Belichick, UNC HC | +600 | 14.3% |
| Todd Monken, Ravens OC | +750 | 11.8% |
| Kevin Stefanski, Browns HC | +1000 | 9.1% |
| Lincoln Riley, USC HC | +1100 | 8.3% |
| Mike McDaniel, Dolphins HC | +1200 | 7.7% |
| Brian Daboll, Giants HC | +1400 | 6.7% |
| Mike Tomlin, Steelers HC | +1400 | 6.7% |
| Ryan Day, Ohio State HC | +1500 | 6.3% |
| Jeff Hafley, Packers DC | +1750 | 5.4% |
| Anthony Weaver, Dolphins DC | +1800 | 5.3% |
| Frank Smith, Dolphins OC | +2000 | 4.8% |
| Deion Sanders, Colorado HC | +2500 | 3.9% |
| The Field | +900 | 10.0% |
Related: Next NFL Coach Fired.
Who Replaces McDaniel? A Look At The Dolphins Candidates
Kliff Kingsbury (Washington Commanders OC)
The former Texas Tech and Arizona Cardinals head coach has had a solid career turnaround in the Nation’s Capital, overseeing the Commanders renaissance offensively. During Kingsbury’s two-year stint as the Commanders’ OC, the team has improved their point total from 25th NFL-wide in 2023 to 5th in 2024, while the team’s yards per game jumped from 24th to 7th during that stretch. For now, Kingsbury holds +500 odds of replacing McDaniel in Miami, starting things off as our top pick to be the next head coach of the storied AFC franchise.
Bill Belichick (UNC head coach)
It seems like a matter of time until Belichick ditches North Carolina to return to the NFL, with a contract buyout that’s already dropped from $10 million to $1 million on June 1, opening the door for the eight-time Super Bowl champion to come back to the 32-team league if he gets the right opportunity.
It’s hard to not see Belichick jumping at the chance to return to the AFC East, too, with the former Patriots sideline legend getting a shot to dish out revenge twice a year, which is part of the reason why we’re giving the 73-year-old +600 odds of taking one final job and finishing his NFL career with a shot at dishing out some comeuppance in Miami Gardens. Winning a few more games in Chapel Hill this season would help convince Dolphins Owner Stephen Ross to pursue him, though.
Promo Code: BOOKIES20X
Todd Monken (Baltimore Ravens OC)
The former Georgia Bulldogs offensive coordinator has been in charge of Baltimore’s scheme since 2023, leading the team to the top-ranked scoring offense in two games this season, a year after Baltimore led the NFL in yard per game while ranking third in terms of points scored.
While Monken has never been an NFL head coach, he did coach Southern Miss from 2013 to 2015, with assistant coaching roles in the NCAA and NFL dating back to his graduate assistant days at Grand Valley State in 1989, with +750 odds of getting that elusive first job running an NFL team in the Dolphins in 2026.
Promo Code: BOOKIES20X
Kevin Stefanski (Cleveland Browns head coach)
Stefanski has gotten the short end of the stick in Cleveland, going 40-46 (.465) with the franchise since taking over as head coach in 2019. He has, however, gotten the club to the postseason twice, going 11-5 in 2020 and 11-6 in 2023, before bottoming out at 3-14 in 2024 and 0-2 this year.
Despite his struggles, we’re giving Stefanski +1000 odds of being the next man up in Miami, should Cleveland opt to start fresh, with a change of scenery potentially opening the door to a brighter future for the 43-year-old that’s won the AP Coach of the Year award twice already.
Lincoln Riley (USC head coach)
While the last two years have been anything but pretty, that’s not to say that the ninth year NCAA head coach is not capable of great things. Riley came to USC as a hot-shot coach, having led Oklahoma to the CFP in 2018, 2019 and 2020, before leaving for Los Angeles in 2022.
With USC sitting pretty at 3-0 and Riley’s coaching stock rebounding thusly, the Dolphins might have to get in line early to get a shot at the 42-year-old, which is why we’re giving them +1100 odds of landing him out of the coaching transfer portal in 2025.
Other Coaches To Keep An Eye On
While we’ve started this list off with outside suitors, that’s not to say that McDaniel can’t do enough to keep his job, with +1200 odds of him returning to Miami in 2026, while three more current head coaches (Brian Daboll of the New York Giants, Mike Tomlin of the Pittsburgh Steelers and Ohio State head coach Ryan Day) are next in line to get the gig, at +1400 (Daboll and Tomlin) and +1500 (Day).
Outside of those men, keep an eye on Green Bay Packers defensive coordinator and former Boston College head coach Jeff Hafley (+1750), as well as Dolphins DC Anthony Weaver (+1800) and OC Frank Smith (+2000) to replace McDaniel, while Colorado Buffaloes head coach and former NFL legend Deion Sanders rounds out our Dolphins head coaching list, at +2500.
Promo Code: BOOKIESBG150
The Money Factory Social Casino Promo Code September 2025 
Caesars Sportsbook Promo Code BOOKIES20X: Get 20 100% Profit Boosts for NFL Weekend, CFB (Sept. 19) 
Fanatics Vermont Promo Code: Get Up $100 No Sweat Bets + $100 in FanCash For NFL Weekend (Sept. 19) 
Caesars Sportsbook Live Streaming: Watch NFL Games on Caesars App (Sept. 19) 
bet365 Bonus Code BOOKIES: Get $200 Betting Bonus for NFL Weekend, CFB (Sept. 19) 
BetFred Ohio Promo Code: Get $1,111 In Bonuses
Comments